| |
In this
chapter, we present two case studies in detail to
exemplify what we have covered in the first two chapters.
There are many implications of these case studies on
research methodology in holistic health.
Some are that they can:Point to a science capable of studying
persons as wholes.
Validate the incorporation of medical anthropology into
the methodology.
Stimulate ordinary people to involve themselves in
clinical research using this case study methods.
lead to an improved model for writing case studies.
lead more people to study and use holistic health healing
therapies.
We are at the fringe of a
new era of healing. We see how we can incorporate all
aspects of a person's life into the healing process. We
see the need for mind exercises to strengthen the immune
system so that we are protected from disease. We see how
to use our psyche positively to keep us healthy.
This case study method forces us to look beyond
pathological tissues to examine the many facets of
psychology, theology, medical anthropology, ecology, and
physiology and determine the cause and cure of disease.
We see how our thoughts, attitudes, feelings, beliefs,
and values effect our health.
We see the marvelous interplay between the mind, the
brain, and the immune system. We can hope from these case
studies that they will change the way approach which
incorporates all methods and aspects into the healing
process. This process will include body, mind, emotions,
spirit, and environment. In the first case study of
Savithri, the chronological structure method is followed.
In the second case study of Kiran, the theory building
structure is followed. Names have been changed to
maintain privacy.
CASE STUDY OF SAVITHRI
Basically human beings
have power within themselves to transform their own lives
as well as that of society. This case study is reflection
of Savithri's search in her healing process. You will see
her struggle in accepting the illness -- the rejection of
allopathic treatment and the frustrations she went
through during the first stage of her illness. Then you
see her accepting the treatment of Ayurveda and massage,
getting better, but again the urge to serve the poor
forced her to go back to the village where she had
started her illness, against the advice of the doctor.
The hardship and stressful situations made her sick
again. She came to the reality that something had to be
done. She bends her heal to the orthopedic doctor and
gets treated with medicines and injections. She felt
ashamed of herself. She accepted that she was sick, and
it is not curable, she has to live with the limitations.
She went for a course to Indian Institute, Bangalore, for
three months. There she learned a lot about social issues
and she planned to work in the future with her
limitations. She planned to be out of the village for
some time, as she saw that she must take care of herself.
She was told to come to Pune for healing. At first she
was reluctant and upset, so she kept ways from the
Holistic Health Centre.
Then she gradually recognised and took full
responsibility for her own healing. Now she is a changed
person and proclaims everywhere about her fullness of
health. It was an adventure for her. She narrates her own
story. Art work was an important part of her healing so
some of the pictures are included.
Phase 1
: Genesis of life
I am one of the
eleven children of my parents. We were seven boys and
four girls. I was a very active and outgoing
child. My mother had to see to all of us. She didn't get
much love and affection from any one of us, nor from my
father. My father was like a stranger to us. He came home
every 15 to 20 days and did not stay for very long at
home. We treated him as a guest. We did not close to him.
I used to watch him. He was a social worker. He was very
busy helping people around us. It was a new place, where
people came from far off places, like us, to settle
there. So he was busy measuring land, surveying the land
for someone else, solving the disputes among them, etc.
We did not include him in our family. He had entrusted
all his responsibility of home to his order sons.
They took responsibility for us. But my parents had no
time for us. We were notorious and did all kinds of
mischief.
I remember one incident very clearly. I was only three
years old. I had a friend who used to come every day to
play with me and I was very fond of him. I use to wait
for him. He was ten years old and deaf and dumb. I did
anything he wanted, as I really experienced his love. My
parents did not want me to play with him because he was
dirty and of a low caste, but I did not care. one day he
took me far away. After walking about ten km., I got
tired and sleepy, so we stopped under a tree and I went
to sleep. My father could not find me at home and were
terrified. At last my sister found me sleeping under the
tree with my friend sitting near me. my sister tied the
boy to a tree and beat him with a stick, and left him
there. I was very angry with my sister. At home they all
teased me about it. This incident was much alive in me
and brought me very close to the poor and oppressed. I
decided that when I grew big, I'd fight for justice and
right. This was a strong power in me from then onwards in
my life.
Between age
4-6 years
As my father was
away much of the time, my mother had added jobs and
couldn't give much attention to us. I remember at that
age we fought for justice and equality. My younger sister
was epileptic and got fits. Mother over protected her,
also other at home. Three of my brothers and myself
decided to stand together to fight against her whenever
we saw that she got something special. We used to gang up
and irritate her trying to take it away, or teasing her.
When she got something she never shared it with us, but
used to eat it in front of us. When we fought with her
she used to cry and my mother used to beat us. Often we
ran away and escaped from her. We refused to include her
in any activities like games, going to the forest for
wood, looking after the animals, going to the fields to
pick berries, etc. The four of us shared whatever we got
and enjoyed our games and play, always leaving her out of
our fun.
My
Experience at School
I was smart at
many things at home, but dull at school from fear of the
teacher. He was a magician and I thought he could put a
spell on me. He was very strict can beat the children, so
I couldn't learn. I thought that I was stupid and
compared myself with my brothers who were clever at
studies. Their teasing also put me down. Sometimes I told
them, " I know how to live and you know books".
I used to absent myself from school frequently playing
hookie. I would to school without brushing my teeth so
they'd send me home, but I would roam and play. See
Pictures 3 and 4. Because of all this I finished my
S.S.L.C. three years later than my classmates.
When I was thirteen years old I suddenly realised that I
was a woman, I did not want to be one. Up till then I had
been completely like my brothers. My mother's
instructions were very strict, I had to stay at home,
learn things around the house, and not move around with
boys. I hated the restrictions as a woman, suffered an
identity crisis and became very depressed. See Picture 5.
After matric I stayed at home for two years and helped my
mother run the house. I was good at it. It was hard for
my family financially. After two years I went to college
and did my B.A. My friendship with my brothers changed
considerably. I become a consultant to them when they
asked my opinion. Our bonds of friendship and support
deepend.
We grew up in a mixed culture and never knew such things
as caste, creed and religion existed. We all played
together and treated each other as equals. I had a few
hobbies; I loved games, liked to sit and watch people,
enjoyed reading and discussions and I loved watching
nature. I did not like any kind of a structured life with
laws -- unless the laws were made in consultation with
those who are involved in keeping them. I had a
disciplined life as my father had give the charge of the
family to my elder brothers. They did it in a very nice
way . Even though we were notorious and active children,
they helped us to become responsible and accountable for
our actions. Every week we had a meeting among us, eight
boys, four girls, and mother.
In Malabar we did not have a church close by,but we did
pray meaningfully. For example, we had our daily prayers,
every week we had a reconciliation ceremony among
ourselves, and open sharing. At this prayer everything
was dealt with. We evaluated the work of each one during
the week, clarified and confronted. Corrections were
given in a very caring and loving way. If any wanted to
do something new it was bought out and discussed.
We had weekly at which mother used to give accounts of
running the house -- whether the money was enough, or she
needed more, and what were the areas where she needed
help. Each one of us were given jobs according to our
capacity and we had to give an account of it in our own
way. At these meetings, if my brothers found that any of
us were hurt during this process, they would spend time
helping the person understand. Because of this I become
assertive when I grew up, and could talk in any group
without fear. In my family I saw that justice was done to
each one. They valued my opinion. for example, one of my
brothers wanted to marry a girl and came to me with this
problem. I told him that if he really loves her and
thinks he would be happy in his life I would support him,
and he married the girl he wanted.
I was good in managing the house and helped in the
marriage of my sisters and brothers, but I never wanted
to marry. I was open and free with everyone. I always
talked to boys freely. When my favourite brother married,
his marriage was arranged by me, with one of my friends.
When his first child was born I was with her in the
hospital. My sister in-law was concerned about me and
told my brother I'm too free with boys and he'd better
find a boy for me and get me married. When I heard this I
was very angry. I refused to speak to them. Meanwhile I
decide to join the convent. My decision made this brother
of mine very angry and guilty -- he kept away from me for
seven years. It was painful for both of us. He thought
that I joined the convent because of them and I will not
be happy. When I brought up the topic in the meetings
about my call for religious life, this brother objected
very strongly. At last my father intervened and gave me
permission.
Phase 2
: Life and Mission/Illness
Life
and Mission
I joined the
convent at the age of 25. The poverty and misery of the
poor people touched me and changed my attitude and
motives. It urged me to be with them and search life
together. Therefore I took the first step towards this
movement, by being with women and children who were the
victims of social evils.I could understand them better
being a woman. I felt the need of some skills which would
equip me for my work. I went to Ambilikkai in Tamil Nadu,
for a two year course on community health guides. The
topics covered were basic nursing and midwifery, and
community organisation and development.
During this course I went to a village called Maner in
Patna, Bihar State, for my field experience. I chose two
villages, and with their permission I did a socio-health
survey. It was done efficiently, but this project was
purely accomplishing my need to complete my studies, not
the left need of the people. It was my first experience
in the village.
After my studies I joined a team of three others who were
involved in the village work. We extended our work to a
few more village where Harijans were a majority. We
trained Harijan women as health workers, but people
didn't accept them. In one village of 100 families,
eleven children died in two months. These tragic deaths
opened my eyes. I saw that I must do something to improve
the situation. It was in 1982 that my enthusiasm and
great desire to serve people met with the realisation of
the depth of the problem they faced.
I plunged into many things, We started motivation
training which helped them to excess themselves. We got
help from Integrated Rural Development Programme (IRDP)
to improve the economic conditions and formed
co-operative societies. We felt, as social workers, we
had a great role to play to bring hope into hopless
situations. We started many schemes under IRDP.
In 1983 I attended on Organizational Development workshop
in Pune. The theme was Contemplation in Action. The
participants were involved with people in difference
degrees as social activists. It was an enriching
experience for me and also a turning point in my life.
All the time I was working for people. This made me to
work with people. With hard work they were able to
express their needs. We also discovered their talents and
abilities. Some key issues. There were a lot of problems
from the landlords. The people were afraid even though
they knew the law. Those who tried to get their right had
to suffer a lot of threats and even one young man of 26
was murdered and thrown in the Ganges.
To be with people and motivate them, two of us stayed in
the village. The living conditions and food were very
bad. But I was not that bothered. We were able to achieve
many things. The law released the bonded laborers from
the obligations to the landlords, the women stood up for
their rights, the children received scholarship, etc. I
learned a lot from the people. Linkage with social action
group was one way we got empowered to go in our
involvement and develop a clarity of vision. Even though
the work increased, to fulfill the obligations, we were
about eleven voluntary groups sharing the work. We used
to meet every month for sharing, supporting, and planning
for future. We started a federation of all the small
organization in 1984. We formed a common goal for all.
This group opened a new door for me in my life. I felt
completely at home with the group. They were ever ready
to help us. So we did lot of group activities I was also
a member of PUCL (people's Union For Civil Liberties). I
was so involved in various activities I id not care for
my comforts.
History
of Illness
My general health
weakened. I felt my internal organs were all out of
order. I suffered from indigestion, amoebiasis,
diarrhoea, ulcer, muscle weakness, sinus trouble
tonsillitis, ear problem headache, etc. This was due to
improper and untimely food, tension, extremes of weather,
lack of clean drinking water, etc. These troubles did not
bear the pain, and the weakness of my hands and legs
increased until I was unable to walk. I felt a kind of
tingling sensation at the tips of my toes and fingers.
See Picture 6.
Hospital
Experience
At last I saw the
doctor in the hospital and he admitted me immediately.
All kinds of investigations were done. I was put on
traction. Lying in bed I felt helpless and hopeless and
very angry inside. See picture 7. I was resistant to the
treatment and thought of all the negative comments made
by other about me. I was in the hospital in this
condition for three weeks. I couldn't accept the illness.
I felt that I am young and have to work, I can't get
sick. I was annoyed with the doctors who kept the
sickness as a secret from the patients. My mind was
divided between sickness and my work. I reacted
negatively to each medicine. I was afraid of becoming
paralyzed and thus becoming a burden for others. I had
prided myself on being an independent person and now I
was completely dependent on others. These factors made me
more sick and drained me emotionally. I couldn't trust
anyone and also questioned God, friendship,and community,
which and previously been of great value to me.
I thought of my family and felt very close to them. My
inner struggle was worse than my physical pain. When the
conflict was too much, see Picture 8 which depicts my
feelings, and I was so full of questions, questions
everything, caught in a darkened image of the world, and
experienced being imprisoned behind bars, only my inner
will kept me alive, I could only run to the security of
my own family. I shared my feeling and instructions with
my mother. I reacted to everything and grew impatient.
See picture 9. I felt my thinking power diminished. I
withdrew from everything. This experience was more
painful for me than my physical pain. I was completely
broken down and could not sort it out. I had lost my way.
Tension was eating me up. My hormones were all out of
balance. This picture shows my defensive reaction :
blowing off at everything.
Together with my mother, we planned that try Ayurvedic
treatment a I was disillusioned with allopathy and I
believed in other systems of medicine. So I went for
Ayurvedic treatment for three months at home they
promised they would cure me and I did get better. During
those months I tried to find out what was going on inside
me, but could not in depth. After three months they told
me I need more rest, but I resisted and came back to the
village to save the people. Even at this stage my goal to
go to the poor made me get up an ignore the mesages of my
body which begged for rest.
After working for six months, my wholebody was swollen,
hands weak, and I was worse then before. I was unable to
walk, I felt helpless, only my inner will kept me up.
Everything was in darkness. Those who had supported me,
left me.
I was taken to an orthopaedic specialist, I kept quiet, I
thought I failed. I did not believe in allopathic
medicine, yet here I was on complete berets for 21 days.
I had X-rays, injections, but I did not rest. In my head
I was doing my future plans -- deciding to take up some
studies to get out of the village. On discharge from the
hospital, I went to the Indian Social Institute,
Bangalore, for three month course on Social analysis.
There I realised that I was not realistic, I must see
what is within my capacity. After finishing this course I
was asked by my Superior to come to Pune for healing. I
had my reservations. See Picture 11. It was a moment of
great confusion for me. It was not my choice. I felt that
I can manage if I was more careful, why waste more time.
I know my capacity now and I will accept my inabilities
an live accordingly, and I was O.K. with it. I was a bit
angry with the suggestion that I go to Pune and so I
arrived with a chip on my shoulder, thinking let me see
how they will cure me!
It took me two months to look into the Holistic Health
approach. I stayed away from the cetre but watched what
happened there. I noticed that I was not forced to do
anything. I was left free. Then I attended a workshop on
Basic Holistic Health during which I kept an open mind,
and forgot my village and my mission. I realised that
there are some facts and common sense in what was said.
This workshop really opened my eyes -- one thing was
clear to me that healing can be done only by my efforts.
A glimmer of hope and brightness came into my life.
Phase 3
: New Life
Symptoms
When I arrived in
Pune I had weakness of the left side, I could not write
with my right hand, couldn't bring my hands close to my
body, had back pain, neck pain, and tingling of hands and
legs.
Treatment
During the Basic
Holistic Health workshop, I realised that I am
responsible for my health. This was something new for me.
The community was very supportive to me. The Holistic
Health team were understanding and never forced me. As I
watched their functioning with other clients, both in the
house and in the centre, I felt confident that I can take
charge of my healing and can get their help.
This was shift in my belief system away from thinking
that I was condemned to invalidism for life, toward using
the healing power within me to be well. The team
explained to me the way to function in my healing
process. They said to patients with myself as it would be
a long slow process. I liked the weaving of knowledge
with treatment, and I felt I was treated as an equal. My
whole person was involved in the diagnosis, selection,
and implementation of the treatment regime. I found the
team firm but compassionate. I attended many workshops.
Basic
Holistic Health : which gave mean understanding of taking a
sick person as a whole, not in part. I saw the importance
of the five dimensions of Holistic Health : Self
responsibility, Nutritional awareness, Stress management,
Social and Environmental sensitivity, and Physical
fitness -- and through these integration of body, mind,
spirit, and emotions. This was the turning point for me
to look into the holistic health approach. I was a bit
shy to approach the team. It took me two weeks to step
into the clinic. My back was hurting very badly, finally
I dropped into the clinic one morning. I was not
questioned -- instead the team welcome to me warmly. They
attended to my back and gave me a realignment therapy. I
felt much better. That gave me confidence that I can be
treated in the centre. As I was going on with the
physical healing, I had a chance to attend the next
workshop.
Stress
Management Workshop : Here I connected my physical pains to the
stressful situations. The inputs were rally good. It was
scientific and I had to say "aha" as the
connections were unfolding. I realized that the whole
sickness did not start two years ago -- it had been
storing up in my mind for long time and the body symptoms
were a result of my inability to cope with my mental
struggle. The workshop helped me to look into my
stressful situations and deal with them rather than
putting them on my life, I got the chance to attend the
next workshop.
Psychosynthesis
and Assertiveness Training : I was happy to attend this workshop
as I knew it will help me to look further into my being.
I was much more relaxed. This was another approach to
unfold other aspects of me. As I was dealing with my
subpersonalities, I realized my weakness and strengths
and how I could integrate them in my life and work.
One of the scenes which came out during this workshop
(mentioned earlier in this case), was the injustice done
to my 10 years old deaf and dumb friend, when I was a
three year old child--standing and crying, angry, and
helpless. I integrated this crying child in me, by
dealing with my sister. The drawings were really
revealing, I enjoyed doing it, even though I am not an
artist. As I was working on these aspects, another
workshop was scheduled which I attended.
Getting the
Meaning of Dreams : I was more and more interested to
unfold myself. I had many dreams. An important area that
was revealed to me was about my father. I was afraid of
dead people : My father died a few years ago. He came
many times in my dreams, but I was afraid to relate to
him. During the dream workshop again he came in my dream.
I shared the dream in the group and the team helped me to
look into myself. I realized that I was angry with my
father as I felt he never cared for us. I couldn't
forgive him. I realized how far I had kept him from my
life and even when he died, I did not feel much. I was
helped to begin a new relationship with my father through
dialogue and healing of memories. Now I experience him
very close to me as a strong resource person. He is a
spiritual energy for me. During this workshop many other
treasures were revealed to me and I experienced the depth
of life and healed many memories.
All through my stay in
Pune I had inputs through seminars, personal counselling,
and I read many beautiful books on healing and applied
them to myself. I am a person who has many questions and
these were answered through the above approaches.
- I learned that
sickness does not happen overnight. There are
many reason to make and unhealthy environment. It
takes a long time to get sick and a long time to
be healed.
- I changed my diet
from non-vegetarian t vegetarian and I felt
better. I followed hydrotherapy and took a lot of
salad with plenty of sprouts, especially wheat. I
look meals at regular times.
- I received
acupressure for neck and back pains on alternate
days for three weeks.
- I received
realignment therapy twice a week for four weeks.
- I was taught, and
continue to follow yoga exercises for the back
and neck.
- I followed
acupressure points for eyes and nose and remedial
exercises for sinus trouble and to improve
vision.
- I took ten days of
magneto therapy.
- I followed relaxation
exercises with guided imagery for 15 minutes
three times a day, drawing the images once a week
to note progress.
- I spent 45 minutes
twice a day at meditation.
After one to two months, I
could experience gradual healing -- I had confidence, was
open and responsible. I did not feel anxious. I spent
time for myself. at age two. It was so surprising all I
had kept in my head.
I gradually integrated all the unresolved parts of me and
accepted my shadow.
In short, the books, treatment, and seminars and
workshops helped me to find out the root cause of my
illness. I looked at my illness with a bodymind approach.
I took full responsibility an looked into myself
objectively. I saw that many events and tensions build up
until finally the body breaks down at its weakest point.
A complete denial of myself was the beginning and when
the body is sick, the mind also is affected. The holistic
health way of dealing with the sick with a compassionate
understanding attitude helped me to deal with my sickness
quite smoothly. This healing was a long, painful, gradual
process which I faced and worked through. I am in touch
with my body now and will never again ignore it or allow
it to break down. I know how to keep myself in balance
and harmony and how to react harmoneously with the
environment. I also realised that life is an integrated
whole and it has to be approached with compassion and
understanding. It is a very difficult phenomena to
realize that the human body is a masterpiece in the total
creation.
For me health is harmony with God, oneself, others, and
with nature. See Picture 14. Imbalance of this harmony is
sickness for me. All putting back into harmony is cure.
All human beings need this harmony. My experience of
healing has become teaching material for me to help
especially the chronically ill. I communicate the
importance of this integrate not only to the sick, but to
the public at large.
This healing process has brought me closer to God. Now I
am able to integrate my work in my life. I spend 45
minutes in the morning and in the evening in quiet
meditation, alone with God. Also whenever I feel tense, I
take some time to meditate and it helps me a lot. I have
become a reflective person. Before these experiences,
Mass was a ritual for me and I missed it many times. But
now it is a cherished experience for me.
I feet that I have made Jesus a part of the Mass is the
culmination of all that I do. I feel now that the
spiritual self, God, is my director. See Pictures 15 and
16 (Picture 15 on page 82)
Staff
Comment
I met Savithri
about year ago when she came for a meeting. It was after
her treatment with Vaidya. She complained of weakness in
her left hand. I gave her acupressure release - she could
not bear the pain.
Acupressure gave her a little relief. But I could see she
did not believe in it. When she came to Pune, I had my
apprehensions and as she said, she was skeptical and
wanted to challenge us.
During the basic Holistic Health Workshop I saw her
getting interested and when she come to the clinic, I was
cautious -- I only attended to her back. Slowly our
relationship warmed up and then I saw she was committed
to a holistic healing process. She was enthusiastic,
honest and open. She had many questions to ask, as she
was growing in learning by unfolding herself. She became
a beautiful person. Her whole personality and
relationship with others were different. She could be
healed not by the doctors, but by herself. She was ready
to take up job when she was well.
Now she is doing a very difficult job with plenty of
travelling and taking responsibility. It is now one year
that she is working there and last week she wrote :
"I had to go to many places and do so many
programmes, but I'm happy to tell you my health is
fine." I am really proud of her. (Comment by Celine
Payyappilly, Co-ordinator Holistic Health Centre )
Lesson
Plan on Savithri's Case Study
Objectives
- To have others
profit by her experience.
- To get others to
open themselves to change and healing.
- To get in touch
with their own experiences.
- To bring hope to
others.
- To touch sympathy,
empathy and eagerness to help others, you reach
out to others to heal themselves, and then to
heal the world.
- To reach
self-responsibility.
Knowledge
At the
end of lesson a student of holistic health should be able
to:
- Know about the
importance of self-responsibility.
- Believe that
knowledge can change beliefs and attitudes.
- See the importance of
balancing personal needs and goals with working
with others.
- Know that we are
human beings and we will get sick, but we should
take responsibility for healing ourselves (
healing is within).
- See how childhood
experiences lead to formation of attitudes.
Experiences help to change attitudes.
- See how physical
sickness does not make a person a cripple, but
the mental and psychological aspects are more
involved in the illness.
- See that social
workers are regarded as morally good people so
they shouldn't get sick. Sickness is regarded as
something not good. So when one is doing good how
can a bad thing such as sickness happen to them.
Social workers need to take care of their own
health so they can take care of others.
- See the importance of
harmony with God, self, others, and the whole
universe.
- Understand that
books, and workshops can enhance knowledge, which
is healing.
Attitudes
- Identify your
attitude towards sickness and health.
- Identify you attitude
towards different systems to medicine.
- Identify your
attitude towards the healer/healee relationship.
Content
The
following points can be considered :
Phase
1 : Early
life
- How childhood hurts
are carried with us until healing of memories is
complete.
- The family structure
and its impact -- in large families the
difficulty of giving sufficient love and
attention to each child - especially when
father's work takes him away from home.
- How teachers and
interactions and comparisons at school effect the
lives of children.
- The frustration felt
by children at unjust punishment.
- How decisions taken
at these early experiences mold and shape our
whole life.
Phase
2 : Life
and Mission/Illness
- The importance of
meaning in life.
- The need to integrate
care of self with mission in life.
Phase
3 : New
Life
- The benefit of
illness.
- The importance of
support groups.
Teaching
Methods
Discussion
and question - answer. The discussion could focus on :
- The group's attitude
towards allopathic treatment.
- Their response to her
story - their emotional response especially when
she was so sick and yet wanting to be involved in
her work.
- The relationship
between healer and healee.
- The relationship
between Savithri and doctors in the hospital.
- The relationship
between Savithri and orthopedic surgeon.
- The relationship
between Savithri and the Ayurvedic doctor.
- The relationship
between Savithri and her family.
- The relationship
between Savithri and her colleagues.
- The relationship to
herself.
- How she balanced the
spiritual, emotional, psychological and physical
aspects in her life.
- The support groups
reaction.
- Identifying the
turning point when she took full responsibility
of herself .
- Listing the positive
and negative factors in the environment which
effected her in this situation.
- Listing her innate
strengths.
- The impact her
illness had on her personality.
Role play her behavior
when she first felt sick.
Use psychodrama on any scene from the case study.
Invite individuals to tell their own story of sickness
and return to health.
Study
Her Beliefs Before Healing
- That her illness was
for life.
- That laws are to be
broken, unless you're involved in making them.
- I should be
unstructured, not tied to an institution.
- Work is more
important than bodily health.
- I can only work in
small teams, where we have participative decision
making.
- If people are
compassionate, I can be okay.
- Work, life's mission
is more important than listening to my needs and
wants.
CASE STUDY OF KIRAN
In this case study of
Kiran, the theory building structure is followed. After
the introduction, Kiran's story is unfold focusing on the
following theories in this order:
Introduction
Kiran is a 56 year
old lady who is still getting help from our Holistic
Health Centre. She is a special case. She had a cerebral
hemorrhage in 1958. She was eight months pregnant at that
time and had some swelling of the feet. She was in bed
for 30 years after this with the left side paralysed. A
month ago, Kiran was walking with the help of her husband
when whey happened to meet one of the staff nurses from
our Holistic Health Centre. They exchanged greetings and
casual talk led to interest in health and healing. Our
staff explained the working of our centre and all that we
were doing to help people who can be healed of their
ailments with various methods of treatment and
participation in self cure.
After this meeting Kiran started to come to the centre
for treatment. I was curious to know what made her get up
from her bed after 30 years. The first visit to the
clinic was very encouraging to her. After the third
visit, she said she was 50 percent improved. She said
previously it took her one hour to walk to the centre,
now she can do it 20 minutes. Because of this remarkable
improvement, I decided to write up her case.
Kiran talks a lot. Her husband is very quiet. Kiran looks
healthy, physically well-built, warm and cheerful,
willing to talk about herself, her illness, and past
history. We observed her warm relationship with her
husband, children and the youngest daughter-in-law, who
was at home with her children. Kiran seems to neglect
dental care, her teeth are badly discoloured, brown with
some teeth missing. She talked about her paralysed left
leg which kept her from walking for many years.
THEORY 1 :
PERSONALITY
Emotional stability is
a very important factor during illness. It is a time when
all of us. regardless of other temperamental
requirements, share the need for self-esteem. To confront
a crisis without self esteem is to be hopelessly adrift
and to experience oneself as naked and defenceless. The
presence or absence of self-esteem has a great impact on
our experience of life, our behaviour and even on our
perceptions of the world. A woman who esteem herself,
feels warmth and gratitude when another expresses
affection for her. A woman with little self-esteem doubts
the authenticity of affection offered.
A person's self-esteem is often wounded by the discovery
that she is seriously ill, and the feeling of
vulnerability that accompanies this loss of self-esteem.
Those with reliant temperaments differ conspicuously from
those with autonomous temperament in how they hope to
reestablish that besieged sense of self-worth. Each of us
silently judges whether or not we are worthy of life. The
origins and standards of this value judgement can be
different for each person. Although both subjective
assessments (worthiness and competence) are important
parts of self-esteem, those with dominant tendencies
toward autonomy are more preoccupied with their sense of
competence. A crisis often forces us to experience the
core of our personal competence.
Childhood
Originally Kiran's
family came from a village called Warmbori near
Ahmednagar, Maharashtra State. Her grandparents were
Marathas. They came to Pune in search of a job. It was
during the British rule. The British converted them into
Christians during the famine. She was born and brought up
in Pune. She lost her mother when she was only five
months old. Her father found it very hard to look after
her. He took her to the orphanage at Panchhowd run by the
Anglican Sisters. Her father used to visit her. He
married three times. She had one sister, four
step-sisters, and two stepbrothers. Her father's main
work was carpentry, but he also was a teacher of
embroidery. He used to teach anyone this trade. Many
girls were his students and Kiran also learned the trade.
When she was five years old, she was sent to a boarding
school, run by the same sisters, called St. Gabriel's.
Kiran was a very active and spunky child. The Sisters
liked her very much. She was good in her studies and in
sports. She was a leader and often was the monitor of her
class. She used to be the spokesman for anything. she was
open and frank and told the truth straight to the person.
She was not afraid of anyone. She liked one girl in the
class. She would do any thing for her, but many others
were afraid of her. Her father was very fond of her. He
was a hot-tempered man and used to get angry with others.
He always did things his own way. When she was 10 years
old he came to the boarding school and told the Sister he
wanted to take her home. The Sisters had nothing to say
as they knew what kind of a person he was. She came home
and still continued her studies. She is very grateful to
the Sisters who did so much for her.
Her illness was a confrontation with self-esteem. She
felt hopelessly adrift to experience the nakedness of
herself. She started to doubt the authenticity of
affection offered. She felt she was a burden to her
husband, and once she told him to leave her and go
somewhere else and live happily. She realized that she
would not be able to get up and walk. This was her own
judgement. She was a more dominant person and was more
concerned with feeling worthy. We could see the crisis of
illness in her. She antagonised everyone at home. The one
who took it badly was her eldest daughter-in -law.
Shailaja. She felt that Kiran did not like her and only
liked her own daughters. Shailaja could not see any good
points in her mother-in-law, who was very impatient.
Kiran could not wait two seconds to get an answer or to
get something. Even if she saw that they were doing
something. Kiran would not wait. She was very hot
tempered. She did not give any consideration to what
others did. Shailaja said that her husband did not earn
much money. After staying six month with the in-laws they
moved out and stayed close by, but Shailaja did not come
to see her mother-in-law, though her children liked the
grandparents. Shailaja agreed that she also is a hot
tempered person like her mother-in-law and she could not
tolerate her anger.
THEORY 2 :
CULTURAL BELIEFS AND CUSTOMS
| God, whose law it is that
he who learns must suffer. Even in our sleep,
pain, that cannot for get falls drop by drop upon
our heart. And in our own despite, against our
will. comes wisdom to us the awful grace of God. -
Aeschylus
|
Religious
Beliefs
Religious
beliefs play an important role in health. For many in
India their work is based on the belief that God rules
things, whether they use the word God or not. If I am
good or have enough faith. "I will not get
sick". This belief may lead the person into self
condemnation when they fall ill. The perspective and
authority of religious belief offers a pathway toward
self-affirmation. A belief in God includes she
confronting belief in universal order. It is a system of
belief in which every occurance has meaning wherther
fully understood or not. The belief that God knows,
acknowledges and understands our suffering provides a
satisfying feeling of recognition. A dynamic life
contains both the inner force of heroic resistance and
the inner force of heroic resistance and the inner force
of acceptance and surrender. There can be no doubt that
the idea of God provides enormous comfort and meaning
belief is capable of furnishing a sustaining strength and
providing deeply meaningful experience during illness. In
India, as a whole, people believe in God. This helps us
to work with them whatever religion they follow.
Marriage
Beliefs
Marriage
beliefs in India are different according to the religion
and the areas. Generally, marriage are arranged by the
parents for their children. In tribal areas they have
gatherings of boys and girls for celebrations. After the
boy asks the parents to the girl to give her in marriage.
Child marriage has been very common, but now it has
reduced through education, government law, and custom.
According to religious customs also the marriage pattern
differs. Usually a man has only one wife. But among
Muslims, they can have more than one wife. After the
death of the thousand the widow ordinarily stays single.
They suffer a lot because of this. The in-laws do not
treat them well. But if a man loses his wife, he can
marry again. Women are dominated by men. The wife has to
serve her husband as God. This is the way a girl is
taught before marriage and it hold true even among many
well educated people.
Divorce is not that common, but within their civil code,
it take place especially among Muslims. Among Christians
it was forbidden, but now there are certain policies
which allow it. It is not that easy as people still feel
and believe that once God unites them, men have no power
to separate. In hardship and in joy they stand together.
If they divorce, they feel guilty. They suffer a lot due
to this belief.
Marriagge
Patterns in General
There
are different patterns of relationship between husband
and wife common to many parts of the world.
Parent-Child
Pattern
Parent-Child
patterns are characterised by well-defined roles. These
marriages are oftern stable and outwardly successful, for
the roles that each willingly and confronting enacts
satisy the majority of their respective needs. Husband
and wifeare able to anticipate and support each other.
They experience a familar identify and each knows what is
expected. They are secure in each other. But when
problems arise, their well-defined roles prove
insufficient to some new circumstance or crisis. Then the
underdeveloped and negected aspects of each partner's
personality are exposed and each may become confused and
vulnerable. The areas of vulnerability are
correspondingly magnified when either the wife or the
husband is threatened with the loss of marriage partner.
- Mother-
Son Relationship
In this
pattern usually the wife takes the dominant role
as mother and treats the husband as son. The wife
is capable of managing the house and the husband
depends upon her. He fails to take responsibility
for the family. In such a situtation, when the
wife gets sick, the husband is at a loss
and find it hard to act as a responsible
father. This pattern can provide an enormous
amount to strength for a family as long as mother
remains strong enough to stay in change of their
lives.
- Father-Daughter
Relationship
In this
pattern the husband assumes the role of
"benevolent big daddy" to his wife whom
he treats as a daughter. He has many of his most
pressing needs satisfied. He is respected,
praised and depended upon, he rarely experiences
uncertainly or personal vulnerability. But his
sense of confidence and control depend upon his
wife's admiration: it is her adoring glance and
needful requests that help maintain his sense of
himself as exclusively wise, kind, strong and
lovable. The husband in a father role rarely get
angry and more often he is a gentle lecturer.
None of these patterns are healthy as they
neglect the right one party. Cultural
prohibitions in India, prevent expression of
emotions. Cultural and religious faith and acts
of human services are encouraged, they are
validated and rewarded. Do not stroke yourself,
do not indulge yourself, cover your feeling up.
We want to accept our feelings and yet each,
although secretly desirous, deprives themself the
right to do so. To feel anything intensely is to
be intensely alive. We long for permission to
accept grief as valid, we seek external
justification for feeling intensely.
What is healthy is a legitimisation of feeling
and emotions which are expressed appropriately.
Wholeness demands expression of feelings.
A marriage pattern that is more common in the
West, and is emerging gradually in India is a
complementary one in which both parties are equal
and interdependent in their relationship. This
includes appropriate expression of feelings. This
pattern is slowly gaining ground against the
strong cultural custom of oppressing women.
Whatever the marriage patterns are, they can be
changed by the individual for the good or bad
according to situation. The responsibility for
change depends upon each person. The ultimate
value of these patterns can be no greater than
the new goals and behaviours which they
encourage. But once they are on the road to
change, a hopeless and embittered family
environment can be changed into one of closeness,
warmth, and exiting growth.
Birth
Control
In
India the Government spends a lot of time and money to
control the population. Many believe the cause of poverty
in India is due to over-population. India has the wealth
to feed its millions but the inequality in the
distribution of wealth is the major cause of increasing
the gap between rich and poor. We see a major portion of
wealth is in the hands of privileged few.
Many of the poor in India are not worried about the
number of children. They believe that the more they have
the merrier. For them children are a blessing from God
and any interference will be punished by God. They
believe if God gives them children, He will also help
them find a way to bring them up. Most people believe in
God. Religious beliefs are very strong. Muslims and
Christians usually are not for family planning. Now
educated people see the need and keep the family small.
If a person goes for sterilisation operation and if any
tragedy such as serious illness or death of their
children occurs, they will say that it is a punishment
from God.
Religious
Belief
For Kiran, health
means happiness, that is being able to work and cope with
life. She is a Christian and has great faith in Jesus.
She belongs to the Free Church. Having a strong faith in
Christ, she believes that whatever happens to her is for
her good. She makes many sweets for Christmas and shares
with her neighbours. She fasts every Friday. She always
keeps flowers in front of a picture of Jesus. If
her husband does not bring flowers she get angry
and grumbles till she gets them. This is very important
for her. She brought up all her children in this
faith. She said that Christ suffered for others and we
should also love and serve others. She has read the
whole Bible five times. God the all powerful and
compassionate father loves her and He looks after her and
her family. She said that she was unconscious for four
days, and God restored her to life. She prays every day
that the Lord may give her strength like Samson and she
will preach His name like Samson as her spiritual healing
symbol. She follows the ten commandments very strictly
and praises God every day. In her life we can see one of
the reason for her survival and her happiness is due to
her religious faith.
Marriage
Kiran started her
periods at the age of eleven. Even though she was only
eleven, she looked as if she was 15 years old. Her father
looked for a boy from that time onwards and she was
married at the age of 13 in 1945. Her husband, Sumant,
was 20 years old. He is a wireman. They stayed in an one
room house in Pune. He is a quiet man and did not get
angry or fight back with anyone. Her father used to get
angry with her husband, but he would never say anything.
Kiran did not allow her father to get angry with her
husband. Instead of Sumant responding, she used to stand
up for him. Sumant also lost his mother when he was
little boy. His father died about six years ago. He had
two brothers and two sisters: One brother was drunkard
and died two years ago in their house. Her husband is the
third child for his parents. Sumant loved his family. His
father did not earn enough. They suffered much from
poverty. Her husband was a very sensitive child and
started working from the age of ten. Her father-in-law
was a pastor. Due to difficulties in the family her
husband had only the minimum education, but he took a lot
of responsibility for the family.
Kiran can read and write Marathi well. She studies till
the seventh standard. She can speak Hindi satisfactorily.
Her husband also can read and write Marathi and can speak
Hindi. Their first child, a baby girl, was born one year
after their marriage. Kiran was still a girl. She did not
know anything about managing a house. She was in a
boarding school and when her father brought her home, her
stepmother took care of the house, and Kiran still
continued as a spoiled child and did whatever pleased
her. She did not know how to cook, clean, or do
housework. When she was expecting the child, she did not
know what it was all about. Her husband was very caring
and loving to her. He married her to have someone to
manage the house. Soon he found out that she was not good
at any of these things, but the understood her. He taught
her everything. She really loved her husband. Their love
was mutual. He was a support and encouragement to her.
Gradually she learned all the housework and managed it
well. She was aware that her husband was struggling to
manage financially. He never showed his tension
externally. But being a sensitive person, she picked it
up, and wanted to help him very much.
She had babies every eighteen months. During pregnancy
she did not have and special diet. She had morning
sickness during every pregnancy for three to five months.
She suffered a lot, but did not go to a doctor as she
considered it a normal phenomena. She used to eat a lot
of sour things like tamarind and green mangoes. She also
like to eat chillies and mud. She loved the smell of the
wet mud during early pregnancy. All her babies were born
in Sasson Hospital. After the delivery, she was well
taken care of . She had a lady helping her at home for
cooking, cleaning, giving bath, and caring of her. Kiran
was given a lot of Methi bhaji ( curry prepared
with tender Fenugreek plants) as it helps in builing up
the blood. She took other green leafy vegetables, roti
made of wheat as well as jowari. Soup was prepared
of head of the goat, and legs as it is believed to give
for general health. Lots of dry fish was given for
production of mill. Panova (Ajuan) leaves were
given with meals for the production of milk and for
digestion. They have three sons an two daughter. Kiran
had one a abortion and a premature stillbirth.
Socioeconomic
and Political Milieu
Kiran lives in
Bibwewadi village. The majority of people are Hindu
Marathas. The standard of living is how. Most of them
belong to lower middle class families. Many of them, like
her have come from far places and live in one-room houses
rented from mainly three families. The living conditions
are poor.
There are only a few bathrooms and toilets which are not
sufficient for all the people. People have little health
awareness. They use the road, lanes, and drains for
toilets. The drains are open. There is municipality water
supply. Very few of them have a water tap in the house.
Children are taught the habit of using the road or
pathways for a toilet. Even ladies do the same. Kiran
does not like this. She keeps her house clean.
They have been staying in an one-room house all these
years. After her youngest son got married, he made a room
on top of the existing room. One can imagine husband and
wife (she an invalid) and five children having to cook,
eat, study, play, and sleep all in one room. They have
municipal water supply and latrine with open drainage
system. They have gas stove. They are non-vegetarian and
eat mutton and eggs. they keep a few chickens. Her
youngest son owns a scooter. He also has made a two
bedroom house with all the facilities, and has given it
on rent for one year. He bought a plot of land, but there
is no water supply nor road. He is waiting for these
facilities to come and then will build or sell it for a
profit. They do not like to move out of Bibwewadi.
The main religious practised are Hinduism, Islam and
Christianity by people living in her area. Many people
work in different offices or as rickshaw drivers, bus
conductors, State transport bus drivers. Some work as
coolies, labourers, business men, and farmers. Many women
work in the farm according to the season. Some of them go
to the marketyard to carry loads. Many women do not have
any work except household work.
Kiran likes to listen to music and watch TV. She enjoys
embroidery and stitching, but now she is not able to do
it. She reads the Bible and prays daily. She likes people
who do good for others and behave well with all. She
likes the children to be calm and quiet and clean. She is
quite fashionable, she likes to dress up well. You can
see her hair style with colourful ribbons and bobbypins.
She likes peace. She does not like proud people, or those
who tell lies. She does not give more importance to sons
than to daughters. She keep away from people who are not
trustworthy. One of her goals in life has been to |